Meet The Cast of The Last Five Years!

Jeffrey Keller (Jamie Wellerstein) is so excited to be making his New Bedford debut in this incredible show! Some past credits include Elf (Buddy), Xanadu (Sonny), Mamma Mia! (Sky), and Legally Blonde (Warner). He received his BFA in musical theatre from Illinois Wesleyan University. Jeffrey would like to thank his parents for their never-ending love and support and Amanda for putting up with him. @jeffrey_keller



Kelsey Seaman (Catherine Hiatt) Credits include the National Tour: Finding Neverland (Ms. Jones, Sylvia u/s). Regional: New London Barn Playhouse: How to Succeed… (Hedy LaRue), The Odd Couple(Cecily Pigeon). Ithaca College: Little Women (Jo March), The Last Five Years (Cathy), A Chorus Line(Maggie). Boston-based doula and podcaster (The Flow). Thank you to my family and to Danny, my forever scene partner! Ithaca College BFA MT ‘18. Website:, Instagram: @kelseyseaman



Carly Caniglia (u/s Catherine Hyatt) is a CA native and graduate of Syracuse University’s Musical Theatre BFA. Credits include Beauty and the Beast and The Last Five Years at Syracuse Stage, Dirty RottenScoundrels and Hairspray at Priscilla Beach Theatre, A Chorus Line and The Wild Party at SU. She is beyond thrilled to have this beautiful experience be her first show back and would like to thank the whole cast, crew, and creative team for a safe, wonderful run. For Mom & Dad.


Daniel Hayward (u/s Jamie Wellerstein) Off-Broadway: Love Actually? The Unauthorized Musical Parody (Liam Nelson, Snape, Others), Black Count of Monte Cristo (Danglers). National Tour: Finding Neverland (Mr. Turpin, JM Barrie u/s). Regional: New London Barn Playhouse: Grease (Vince Fontaine), Mystery…Drood (Bazzard). Forestburgh Playhouse: Fiddler… (Perchik), Kiss Me, Kate (Gen. Harrison Howell, Fred u/s). Ithaca College: The Last Five Years (Jamie), Wonderful Town (Robert Baker), Dogfight (Boland). All my love to Kelsey, so happy we get to return to this piece together! Boston-based actor/drummer/chef, Ithaca College BFA MT ‘18. Website:,